Guides · Repayment

PAYE and ICR are ending in 2028: what physicians should do

Updated November 2026 · What ends, what happens if you do nothing, and where to land
Under the 2025 federal law (OBBBA), the PAYE and ICR income-driven plans end on June 30, 2028. PAYE and ICR ending in 2028 changes the math for any physician currently on them or counting those payments toward PSLF. Here is exactly what changes, what happens if you do nothing, and why IBR (or the new RAP) is almost certainly your next plan.
PAYE and ICR ending in 2028 — what survives (IBR, RAP)
AttendingFi — educational estimate, not advice.

What PAYE and ICR ending in 2028 means

The 2025 reconciliation law reshaped income-driven repayment. SAVE was vacated by the courts on March 10, 2026, and SAVE borrowers are being moved to other plans. PAYE and ICR end on June 30, 2028. Borrowers still on them who haven’t chosen a new plan are moved to RAP on July 1, 2028 (or to IBR for loans RAP can’t take). The two income-driven plans that survive are IBR (which existed already) and the new Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP), which launched July 1, 2026. So by 2028 your income-driven choices are IBR or RAP, and IBR stays open only if all your loans were disbursed before July 1, 2026 and you haven’t borrowed or consolidated since.

PAYE and ICR ending: PAYE and ICR are ending in 2028: what physicians should do

PAYE and ICR ending: the key dates

DateWhat happens
July 4, 2025The 2025 federal law (Public Law 119-21) is enacted and sets the end date for PAYE and ICR.
July 1, 2026RAP launches. Anyone with a loan or consolidation disbursed on or after this date is limited to RAP or Tiered Standard and can’t use PAYE, ICR or IBR.
Now through June 30, 2028PAYE and ICR stay available to borrowers already on them who have no post-July-2026 loan. ICR payments made by June 30, 2028 count toward PSLF.
Before July 1, 2028Choose RAP, IBR, or a standard, graduated or extended plan.
July 1, 2028ICR’s legal authority is repealed. Anyone still in PAYE or ICR who hasn’t chosen is placed in RAP, or in IBR for loans RAP can’t take.

Who is still on PAYE or ICR

Three groups of physicians are most likely to be affected by PAYE and ICR ending:

  • Attendings who enrolled in PAYE years ago, often during residency, and stayed for the 10% payment and, in the engine’s model, its 10-year Standard cap.
  • Borrowers who used ICR, sometimes as a route into PSLF, or because it was the only income-driven plan available to a particular loan.
  • Parents with consolidated Parent PLUS loans, for whom ICR is the only income-driven plan. ED moves them to IBR after June 30, 2028. The Parent PLUS deadline page covers that path.

Can you still join PAYE or ICR today? That is uncertain. The current regulation text still requires that you were already repaying under PAYE or ICR on July 1, 2024, a 2025 rule had moved that cutoff to July 1, 2027, and the March 2026 vacatur of the SAVE rule may have removed the restriction altogether. We could not confirm ED’s current practice, so ask your servicer before planning around a new PAYE enrollment. Anyone who has received a loan on or after July 1, 2026 is out of PAYE and ICR either way.

What happens if you do nothing

If you don’t pick a plan by July 1, 2028, the Department of Education moves you to RAP (or to IBR for loans RAP can’t take). That keeps an income-driven payment, but it may not be your cheapest one: RAP has no payment cap, while IBR’s payment can never exceed the 10-year Standard amount. For a high-earning attending, being placed in RAP by default can cost more than choosing IBR yourself. Pick deliberately.

Your PSLF count is preserved when you switch

Good news for anyone pursuing Public Service Loan Forgiveness: switching between qualifying income-driven plans does not reset your PSLF count — your qualifying months carry over. The risk isn’t the switch itself; it’s sitting in forbearance, where months generally don’t count. Certify your employment (submit your ECF) when you change plans so every qualifying month is logged.

Where physicians should land: IBR or RAP

The answer turns on a date most physicians have forgotten: when you took out your first federal loan. IBR comes in two versions. “New borrowers” (no balance on July 1, 2014, first loan after that and before July 1, 2026) pay 10% of discretionary income with forgiveness at 20 years. Everyone else pays 15% with forgiveness at 25 years. ED says it cannot extend the 10% version to borrowers outside that 2014–2026 window, so a PAYE borrower who first borrowed before July 2014 lands on 15% IBR.

That changes the comparison. Hypothetical attending: AGI $300,000, single, $300,000 at 6.5%, nonprofit employer pursuing PSLF, AttendingFi engine estimates:

Plan after PAYE endsFirst borrowed after July 1, 2014First borrowed before July 1, 2014
IBR monthly$2,301 (10%)$3,406 (15%, capped at 10-year Standard)
RAP monthly$2,500$2,500
PSLF total on IBR$304,552$408,773 (nothing left to forgive)
PSLF total on RAP$328,492$328,492

For the newer borrower, capped IBR saves about $24,000 over RAP: IBR’s payment can never exceed the 10-year Standard amount, while RAP is a straight percentage of your full AGI with no cap. For the older borrower, the default into RAP is about $80,000 cheaper than choosing IBR, because 15% of discretionary income already exceeds the cap. RAP’s other advantage is that, when you pay on time, interest your payment doesn’t cover isn’t charged. There is no universal answer — compare both on your real numbers with our RAP vs IBR breakdown and the free repayment calculator.

ICR borrowers: a different starting point

ICR payments are usually the highest of the income-driven plans. As AttendingFi models it, ICR charges 20% of income above 100% of the poverty guideline, limited to a 12-year amortized amount, with forgiveness at 25 years. For the $300,000 attending above, that is about $3,006 a month, against $2,301 on new-borrower IBR and $2,500 on RAP. Most physicians still on ICR will see their payment fall when they move.

ICR also treats marriage differently. Under RAP, IBR and PAYE, filing separately keeps your spouse’s income out of the payment. ICR does the same unless you and your spouse elected joint ICR repayment, in which case both incomes and both balances count. If you are married and on ICR, check which version you are on before comparing.

What happens to your forgiveness clock

PAYE and ICR ending does not wipe out the years you have already paid. For RAP’s 30-year forgiveness, qualifying months include PAYE and ICR payments made before July 1, 2028, along with prior on-time IBR payments and certain deferments. For PSLF, ICR payments count if made by June 30, 2028, and IBR and RAP payments count after that.

Two caveats. RAP forgiveness requires that your most recent payment was made under RAP. And any IDR forgiveness outside PSLF after Dec 31, 2025 is federally taxable, so a PAYE borrower counting down to 20-year forgiveness should budget for the tax; the tax bomb calculator estimates it. PSLF forgiveness stays tax-free.

PAYE and ICR ending at each career stage

Resident or fellow on PAYE. At a $65,000 AGI, single, PAYE and new-borrower IBR both come to about $342 a month in the engine, and RAP to $325. The monthly gap is small. The bigger differences are interest and the cap later: on-time RAP payments don’t accrue unpaid interest, while IBR caps the payment once you are an attending. If you plan to train past mid-2028, you will make this choice before you finish, so model the attending years, not just this year.

Attending at a nonprofit, pursuing PSLF. Lowest qualifying payment wins, because the remainder is forgiven tax-free. Use the table above: new borrowers usually want IBR, pre-2014 borrowers often want RAP.

Attending in private practice, not pursuing PSLF. The income-driven choice may matter less than whether to stay federal at all. In the same $300,000 example, the engine’s cheapest path is refinancing now at illustrative mid-2026 refinance rates, about $335,493 in total, against $460,413 on RAP and $482,335 on IBR. Refinancing gives up federal protections and PSLF for good, so it fits borrowers with stable income and no forgiveness plans. See should I refinance.

How to switch off PAYE or ICR

  1. Log in to StudentAid.gov and confirm your plan, loan types and the disbursement date of every loan, including any consolidation.
  2. Run IBR and RAP on your numbers, including whether you are a pre-2014 borrower.
  3. Submit the income-driven repayment application for the plan you chose, with current income documentation.
  4. Expect a short processing forbearance. A plan-change processing forbearance can last up to 60 days, and it counts toward IDR forgiveness and PSLF.
  5. Check the first bill against your estimate, and certify PSLF employment if it applies.

Your action checklist before 2028

  • Confirm your current plan at studentaid.gov — know whether you’re on PAYE, ICR, SAVE forbearance, or IBR.
  • Decide IBR vs RAP on your numbers, not a rule of thumb — run the optimizer.
  • Don’t get placed in RAP by default — if IBR’s cap is cheaper for you, choose it before July 1, 2028.
  • Certify PSLF employment annually and when you switch plans, so qualifying months aren’t lost.
  • Pre-2014 borrower? Check whether your IBR would be the 15%/25-year version. If so, RAP may be cheaper than IBR, and the default may suit you.
  • Don’t borrow or consolidate before you switch. A consolidation disbursed on or after July 1, 2026 removes IBR, PAYE and ICR for all your loans.
  • Married? Filing separately keeps your spouse’s income out of both IBR and RAP payments — see is filing separately worth it.

Frequently asked questions

Are PAYE and ICR really going away?

Yes. Under the 2025 federal law they end on June 30, 2028. IBR remains for borrowers whose loans were all disbursed before July 1, 2026, and RAP launched July 1, 2026.

What happens to my PSLF payments if I switch plans?

Your qualifying PSLF count carries over when you move to another qualifying income-driven plan — it does not reset. Certify your employment when you switch.

Will my payment go up when PAYE or ICR ends?

If you do nothing, you are moved to RAP on July 1, 2028 (or IBR for loans RAP can’t take). RAP has no payment cap, so for a high earner it can cost more than IBR. Choose the plan that fits your numbers before then.

Should I move to IBR or RAP?

If you first borrowed after July 1, 2014, capped 10% IBR is often cheaper than uncapped RAP for high earners pursuing PSLF. If you first borrowed before July 1, 2014, IBR is 15% of discretionary income and RAP is often cheaper. Model both on your numbers.

Can I still enroll in PAYE in 2026?

Uncertain. The current regulation text still limits PAYE and ICR to borrowers who were repaying under them on July 1, 2024, and it is unclear whether later rule changes and court rulings have lifted that. Ask your servicer. Anyone with a loan made on or after July 1, 2026 cannot use PAYE or ICR.

Do my PAYE years count toward RAP forgiveness?

Yes. RAP's 360 qualifying payments include PAYE and ICR payments made before July 1, 2028, as long as your most recent payment is under RAP.