RAP vs IBR (2026 rules): which repayment plan is cheaper?
How RAP works
The Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP) launched July 1, 2026. Your payment is a percentage of your full adjusted gross income (AGI), not a marginal rate: from 1% at low incomes up to 10% once AGI is over $100,000. It is reduced by $50 a month for each dependent you claim, with a $10 monthly minimum. If an on-time payment reduces principal by less than $50, the government adds a principal match, limited by the amount you paid. There is no payment cap, so the payment keeps rising with income.
Its key benefit: when you pay on time, interest your payment doesn’t cover isn’t charged, so the balance doesn’t snowball. Forgiveness comes after 30 years, or 120 payments under PSLF. One filing nuance worth knowing: under RAP, as under IBR, filing separately keeps your spouse’s income out of the payment. Only the dependents on your own return count.
How IBR works
Income-Based Repayment (IBR) charges 10% of your discretionary income if you’re a “new borrower” (no federal loan balance as of July 1, 2014 — which describes most current residents and attendings), or 15% otherwise. Discretionary income is your AGI minus 150% of the federal poverty line for your family size. Critically, IBR is capped at the standard 10-year payment, so it can never exceed the standard amount. Forgiveness comes after 20 years for new borrowers (25 for older borrowers), or 120 payments under PSLF.
RAP vs IBR at a glance
| Feature | RAP | IBR (new borrower) |
|---|---|---|
| Payment | 1–10% of full AGI | 10% of discretionary income |
| Payment cap | None | 10-year Standard payment |
| Unpaid interest | Not charged if paid on time | Accrues |
| Dependent reduction | −$50 per dependent | — |
| Forgiveness term | 30 years | 20 years |
| PSLF-eligible | Yes (120 payments) | Yes (120 payments) |
| Switch to Standard later | Yes (see FAQ) | Yes |
| Who can use it | Any Direct Loan borrower (not Parent PLUS) | Only if all loans were disbursed before July 1, 2026 and you haven’t borrowed or consolidated since |
RAP vs IBR monthly payment, by income
Hypothetical example: a $300,000 federal balance at 7.5%, single, family size 1, all loans disbursed before July 1, 2026, not pursuing PSLF. RAP is a share of your full AGI. IBR is 10% of discretionary income, capped at the 10-year Standard payment, which is about $3,561/mo here.
| Attending income (AGI) | RAP / mo | IBR / mo | Lower payment |
|---|---|---|---|
| $150,000 | $1,250 | $1,051 | IBR |
| $200,000 | $1,667 | $1,467 | IBR |
| $250,000 | $2,083 | $1,884 | IBR |
| $300,000 | $2,500 | $2,301 | IBR |
| $400,000 | $3,333 | $3,134 | IBR |
| $500,000 | $4,167 | $3,561 (capped) | IBR |
On payment size alone, IBR runs about $200 a month below RAP at every attending income up to the cap. RAP passes IBR’s capped payment once income tops about $427,000; IBR itself hits the cap near $451,000. (Starting payments computed by the AttendingFi engine, November 2026. Payments change every year as income changes.)
Why IBR runs about $200 a month below RAP
The gap is not a coincidence. IBR subtracts 150% of the federal poverty guideline from your AGI before applying its 10%. RAP subtracts nothing: once AGI is over $100,000, it takes 10% of every dollar.
The AttendingFi engine uses a 2026 poverty guideline of $15,960 for a household of one, so IBR shelters 150% of that, or $23,940. Ten percent of $23,940 is $2,394 a year, which is $199.50 a month. That is the whole difference for a single borrower above $100,000 of AGI.
The shelter grows with family size. In the engine, each extra household member adds $5,680 to the guideline, so a family of three shelters $40,980 and the IBR discount over RAP before dependents grows to about $342 a month. RAP fights back with its $50-per-dependent reduction, so for a family of three with two dependents the net gap is about $242 a month in IBR’s favor at attending income.
RAP vs IBR on total cost, not just the monthly bill
A lower payment is not the same as a lower total. On a non-PSLF path, a lower payment can stretch repayment out, add interest and leave a balance that is forgiven and then taxed: IDR forgiveness after Dec 31, 2025 is federally taxable. The same hypothetical $300,000 at 7.5%, with 2% annual raises:
| Attending AGI | RAP total paid | IBR total paid | What drives it |
|---|---|---|---|
| $150,000 | $723,620 | $617,050 | IBR forgives about $647k at 20 years; the estimated tax (about $300k) is included |
| $200,000 | $809,894 | $613,160 | RAP runs long; IBR forgives about $380k, with about $175k of tax |
| $250,000 | $609,953 | $611,409 | Near tie |
| $300,000 | $510,989 | $544,910 | Both pay off in full; RAP’s higher payment retires the debt faster |
| $500,000 | $394,384 | $427,326 | IBR is pinned at the cap; RAP pays faster |
Totals are nominal dollars and include estimated federal and state (NY) tax on any non-PSLF forgiveness. In this same example, refinancing now at illustrative mid-2026 refinance rates costs about $335,493 in total, less than either plan, for borrowers who can afford a short term and are not pursuing PSLF. That is why the RAP vs IBR question is often the wrong first question for a private-practice attending: the cheaper path may be neither plan. The refinance vs PSLF breakdown covers that fork.
Residents: which plan wins during training
For a resident the numbers are small but the interest treatment differs. Hypothetical PGY-1 at $65,000 AGI with $300,000 at 6.5%:
- Single, no dependents: RAP is $325/mo (6% of $65,000 ÷ 12); IBR is $342/mo. RAP is lower by $17.
- Family of three, two dependents: RAP is $225/mo ($325 minus $100); IBR is $200/mo, because IBR’s poverty deduction now shelters $40,980. IBR is lower by $25.
The monthly difference is noise. What matters more is interest. Monthly interest on $300,000 at 6.5% is about $1,625. On RAP, if you pay on time, the interest your payment doesn’t cover is not charged, and the principal match can reduce principal by up to $50 a month, limited by what you paid. On IBR, unpaid interest generally keeps accruing. If you are not headed for PSLF, that difference compounds over a three- to seven-year residency. For trainees, the RAP plan for residents guide goes deeper.
Married: filing separately under either plan
Under RAP, as under IBR and PAYE, a married borrower who files separately counts only their own AGI. Only the dependents on your own return count toward RAP’s $50 reduction. Hypothetical: attending at $300,000, spouse at $200,000, family size 2, $300,000 at 6.5%, nonprofit employer, PSLF:
| Filing | IBR / mo | RAP / mo | Lowest PSLF total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jointly | $3,406 (capped) | $4,167 | About $381k–$409k; little or nothing left to forgive |
| Separately | $2,230 | $2,500 | $296,032 on IBR, with $163k forgiven tax-free |
Those totals do not include the extra income tax a couple may pay by filing separately, which can erase part of the gain. The MFJ vs MFS guide walks through that trade-off.
Who each plan favors
IBR tends to win for high earners with a moderate balance, because the 10-year Standard cap freezes the payment while RAP’s keeps climbing. A $300k attending can hit that cap.
RAP tends to win in low-income years (residency, fellowship, a non-working spouse) and when the balance is large relative to income, because on-time payments stop unpaid interest from building up.
The PSLF angle
If you’re pursuing PSLF, both RAP and IBR generate qualifying payments — so you usually want whichever produces the lowest payment for 120 months, since the remaining balance is forgiven tax-free anyway. Which one that is for a trainee depends on your income, family size and how far IBR’s poverty-line deduction goes, so confirm on your numbers. Two things to know: PAYE and ICR end June 30, 2028, which leaves IBR as the long-term capped plan, but only for borrowers whose loans were all disbursed before July 1, 2026 and who haven’t borrowed or consolidated since. Any new loan after that date limits all your loans to RAP or the Tiered Standard plan.
Hypothetical attending at $300,000 with $300,000 at 6.5% at a nonprofit hospital: capped IBR under PSLF totals $304,552 with $151,095 forgiven tax-free; RAP under PSLF totals $328,492 with $117,498 forgiven. That is about $24,000 in IBR’s favor, roughly the $200-a-month gap times 120 payments. For a PGY-1 starting the same path at $65,000, the engine’s cheapest route is RAP during training and capped IBR as an attending ($195,668 total). That switch is open to borrowers whose loans all predate July 1, 2026, who may change plans at any time; IBR’s cap is fixed at the 10-year Standard amount when they first enter IBR.
Borrowed before July 2014? The 15% IBR exception
Everything above assumes you are an IBR “new borrower”: no federal loan balance on July 1, 2014, and a first loan between July 1, 2014 and June 30, 2026. Those borrowers pay 10% of discretionary income, with forgiveness at 20 years. If you still owed a federal balance on July 1, 2014, often from undergraduate loans, you are on the older version of IBR: 15% of discretionary income, with forgiveness at 25 years.
That 5-point difference flips RAP vs IBR for many attendings. Hypothetical: attending at $300,000, single, $300,000 at 6.5%, all loans disbursed before July 1, 2026, nonprofit employer, PSLF.
| Plan | Payment / mo | PSLF total paid | Forgiven tax-free |
|---|---|---|---|
| IBR, new borrower (10%) | $2,301 | $304,552 | $151,095 |
| RAP | $2,500 | $328,492 | $117,498 |
| IBR, pre-2014 borrower (15%) | $3,406 (capped) | $408,773 | $0 |
At 15%, discretionary income of $276,060 produces about $3,451 a month, above the $3,406 10-year Standard cap on $300,000 at 6.5%. IBR is pinned at the cap, the loan is fully repaid in 120 payments, and PSLF forgives nothing; the total matches the engine’s 10-year Standard total. RAP, with no cap but a lower starting payment, leaves $117,498 to forgive. For pre-2014 borrowers, RAP is often the cheaper PSLF plan, so check your earliest disbursement date on your federal aid record before you assume IBR wins.
The trap: a new loan or consolidation after July 1, 2026
Every IBR figure on this page assumes all of your federal loans were disbursed before July 1, 2026. Take out any new federal loan, or a Direct Consolidation Loan, disbursed on or after that date, and all of your loans, old and new, are limited to RAP or the Tiered Standard plan. ED uses the disbursement date, not the application date. Tiered Standard doesn’t count for PSLF, so for a PSLF-bound physician RAP becomes the only qualifying option.
The moves that usually trigger it:
- A fellowship or second-degree loan. Even a small federal loan for an MPH or MBA moves your whole balance to the new regime.
- Consolidating to “clean up” servicers or to bring older loans into PSLF. A consolidation disbursed after June 30, 2026 is a new loan for this rule.
- Re-borrowing after a leave or a program change. Check the disbursement date, not the date you applied.
What it costs, in the engine’s hypothetical PGY-1 at $65,000 with $300,000 at 6.5%, heading to $270,000 at a nonprofit on PSLF: with all loans pre-July 2026, the cheapest path (RAP in training, capped IBR as an attending) totals $195,668. With a post-July 2026 loan, the only PSLF path is RAP throughout, at $212,426, about $16,800 more. Model a new loan before you sign for it; the legacy-borrower trap guide covers the edge cases.

Frequently asked questions
Is RAP or IBR better for PSLF?
For PSLF you generally want the lowest monthly payment over your 120 qualifying payments, because the remaining balance is forgiven tax-free regardless of plan. Which plan that is depends on your income, family size, balance and how far IBR's poverty-line deduction goes, so model both.
Is the new IBR the same as PAYE?
No. PAYE and ICR end June 30, 2028, while IBR stays, but IBR is open only to borrowers whose loans were all disbursed before July 1, 2026 and who haven't borrowed or consolidated since. New-borrower IBR uses 10% of discretionary income with a 20-year forgiveness term.
Can I switch from RAP to a standard plan later?
Yes. If you have a loan made on or after July 1, 2026, you can move between RAP and the Tiered Standard plan at any time, though Tiered Standard payments don't count toward PSLF. If all your loans predate July 1, 2026, you can change to any plan you're eligible for at any time, including from RAP back to IBR or to the 10-year Standard plan, which does count for PSLF.
At what income does RAP cost more than IBR?
On the monthly payment, RAP is higher than IBR at almost every attending income, by about $200 a month for a single borrower, because IBR subtracts 150% of the poverty guideline first. On total cost, it depends on the balance. In our $300,000-at-7.5% example IBR costs less in total below about $250,000 of AGI and RAP costs less above it, because RAP's higher payment retires the debt sooner.
Is RAP vs IBR different for residents?
Yes. At a $65,000 resident salary the payments are close ($325 on RAP vs $342 on IBR for a single borrower), but RAP doesn't charge unpaid interest when you pay on time, while IBR lets it accrue. For a larger family IBR's payment is usually lower because its poverty deduction grows with household size.
Does filing separately lower a RAP payment?
Yes. Under RAP, as under IBR and PAYE, filing separately keeps your spouse's AGI out of the payment calculation. Whether it saves money overall depends on the extra tax you pay by filing separately.
Does RAP really have no payment cap?
Yes. RAP is a straight percentage of your full AGI with no ceiling, so a high earner's RAP payment can exceed the 10-year standard amount, which is exactly why IBR's cap can make IBR cheaper at attending income.
Does the plan I pick change my PSLF eligibility?
No, as long as it is a qualifying plan. RAP, IBR and the 10-year Standard plan all count toward PSLF's 120 payments; the Tiered Standard plan does not. The plan you choose sets your payment, and therefore how much is left to forgive tax-free at payment 120. See how PSLF works for physicians.
What changes for RAP vs IBR if I borrow after July 1, 2026?
Any loan or consolidation disbursed on or after July 1, 2026 limits all of your loans to RAP or the Tiered Standard plan, removing IBR, PAYE and ICR. If you may borrow again, for a fellowship or another degree, model the effect first.
Does RAP or IBR affect the tax bomb?
Indirectly. IDR forgiveness outside PSLF after Dec 31, 2025 is federally taxable, on RAP and IBR alike. The plan you choose changes how much balance remains to be forgiven, and so the size of any eventual tax bill. PSLF forgiveness stays tax-free. The tax-bomb guide covers how to plan for it.
Free, no login, no email. Compare every plan’s monthly payment, total cost and forgiveness on your real balance and income.
Run your own numbers →