Compare student loan plans side by side
Compare IBR, RAP, Standard and PSLF on your real numbers and see your total lifetime cost and forgiveness — not just the monthly payment. Built on the July 1, 2026 federal rules from Public Law 119-21. Free, no login, no email. Last updated November 2026.
Understand each plan
Plain-language explainers for the plans this calculator compares:
- RAP vs IBR (2026 rules) — which plan is cheaper, and why
- How IDR payments are calculated — discretionary income and the formula
- What counts as a qualifying PSLF employer
- Refinance vs PSLF — the one question that decides it
- MFJ vs MFS for student loans — how filing status changes your payment
- Our methodology — every formula and the federal rules behind it
- Married? MFJ vs MFS couple calculator — for couples deciding how to file
How the 2026 income-driven plans compare
After the SAVE plan was struck down, current borrowers choose between IBR (if all their loans were disbursed before July 1, 2026 and they haven’t borrowed or consolidated since) and the new Repayment Assistance Plan (RAP). RAP is a tiered 1–10% of your full AGI (reaching 10% over $100k) with no payment cap, but it waives unpaid interest on on-time payments, so your balance can't snowball.
IBR is 10% of your discretionary income — 15% if you first borrowed before July 1, 2014 — and is capped at the 10-year Standard payment. That cap is usually the deciding factor: as your income rises, RAP's payment keeps climbing while IBR's can't exceed the cap. The only honest way to choose is to compare total lifetime cost, including any forgiveness and its taxes — which is exactly what this tool does.
If you work for a nonprofit or government employer, PSLF forgives your remaining balance tax-free after 120 qualifying payments, which usually makes the lowest income-driven payment the cheapest overall path. If you're not pursuing forgiveness, the Standard plan or refinancing privately is often cheaper. Our refinance lender comparison shows what each lender offers if you go that route.
Compare student loan plans side by side: the 2026 menu
Before you compare student loan plans on cost, check which ones you can actually use. Since July 1, 2026 the answer depends mostly on one date: when your loans were disbursed. This matrix puts every federal option, PSLF and a private refinance in one place. For how the options usually rank at each career stage, see the best repayment plan for physicians.
| Plan | Who can use it | Payment basis | Cap | Ends in | Counts for PSLF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10-year Standard | Loans disbursed before July 1, 2026 | Fixed amortization | — | Payoff, 10 yrs | Yes |
| Tiered Standard | Anyone with a loan made on or after July 1, 2026 | Fixed; 10–25 yrs by balance (25 yrs at $100k+) | — | Payoff | No |
| IBR | Only if all loans were disbursed before July 1, 2026, with no borrowing or consolidation since | 10% (or 15%) of AGI above 150% of poverty guideline | 10-year Standard | Taxable forgiveness at 20 or 25 yrs | Yes |
| RAP | Any Direct Loan borrower except Parent PLUS | 1–10% of full AGI, −$50 per dependent, $10 minimum | None | Taxable forgiveness at 30 yrs | Yes |
| PAYE / ICR | Legacy borrowers only; new enrollment uncertain | Share of discretionary income | PAYE: yes | Plans end June 30, 2028 | Yes, until then |
| Private refinance | Credit-approved borrowers | Fixed private rate and term | — | Payoff, 5–20 yrs | No (no longer federal) |
Three rows drop out for many physicians. A new federal loan or consolidation since July 1, 2026 removes IBR, PAYE, ICR and the 10-year Standard plan for all your loans, leaving RAP or Tiered Standard. The legacy-borrower trap explains why that applies even to students who kept the old loan limits. Former SAVE borrowers must choose from this list within the window on their servicer notice, at least 90 days. And refinancing is one-way: once the debt is private, federal plans and PSLF no longer apply to it.
One physician, every plan: a side-by-side example
Hypothetical PGY-1: $300,000 of federal loans at 6.5%, all disbursed before July 1, 2026, single, three years of training at $65,000, then $270,000 as an attending in New York, 2% yearly raises. The AttendingFi engine ranks every path by total paid, in nominal dollars, including estimated tax on any non-PSLF forgiveness.
| Path | Nonprofit employer (PSLF) | Private employer |
|---|---|---|
| PSLF: RAP in training, then capped IBR | $195,668 | n/a |
| PSLF: capped IBR | $196,286 | n/a |
| PSLF: RAP | $212,426 | n/a |
| Refinance now (lowest-cost term) | $335,493 | $335,493 |
| 10-year Standard | $408,773 | $408,773 |
| RAP to payoff | $498,592 | $498,592 |
| ICR | $536,916 | $536,916 |
| IBR or PAYE with taxable forgiveness at 20 yrs | $593,021 | $593,021 |
Read across, not down. With a qualifying employer, the three PSLF paths beat everything else by more than $120,000. Without one, the same borrower's cheapest federal plan in this example is the 10-year Standard, and refinancing at illustrative mid-2026 refinance rates (5-yr 4.49% up to 20-yr 5.99%) is cheaper still. The top PSLF row switches from RAP to IBR after training, which is open to borrowers whose loans all predate July 1, 2026 but not to anyone with a later loan.
Monthly payment vs total cost: why the rankings differ
Sort the same plans by monthly payment and you get a different winner. Take a hypothetical attending already at $300,000 of AGI in private practice, with the same $300,000 at 6.5%:
| Plan | Starting monthly | Total paid |
|---|---|---|
| IBR | $2,301 | $482,335 |
| RAP | $2,500 | $460,413 |
| ICR | $3,006 | $432,830 |
| 10-year Standard | $3,406 | $408,773 |
| Refinance | $5,592 | $335,493 |
The lowest bill is the most expensive plan, and the highest bill is the cheapest. Off PSLF, a smaller payment usually means more months of interest. On PSLF, the order flips, because the unpaid balance is forgiven tax-free. A side-by-side comparison only helps if it shows both columns.
How to compare student loan plans in three questions
- Will you work full-time for a qualifying nonprofit or government employer for 10 years? If yes, compare the PSLF columns and pick the lowest qualifying payment. PSLF forgiveness is tax-free, and the 2025 employer rule that would have let ED disqualify some employers was vacated in court; ED dropped its appeals in October 2026.
- Which plans are still open to you? Check the disbursement date of every loan and any consolidation on StudentAid.gov. One post-July-1-2026 disbursement narrows the menu to RAP or Tiered Standard.
- How big is the balance relative to income? A balance well above one year of attending income can make 20- or 30-year forgiveness tempting, but that forgiveness is now federally taxable. Compare the total with the tax included, not the payment.
For the formulas behind each plan, see how IDR payments are calculated. For the RAP-or-IBR decision specifically, see RAP vs IBR.
Comparing plans when you're married
Filing status can reorder the whole table. For RAP, IBR and PAYE, a married borrower who files separately counts only their own AGI. Hypothetical: attending at $300,000, spouse at $200,000, family size 2, $300,000 at 6.5%, nonprofit employer. Filing jointly, IBR is capped at $3,406 a month and PSLF forgives nothing. Filing separately, IBR drops to $2,230 and the PSLF total falls to $296,032, with $163,051 forgiven tax-free. The extra tax from filing separately is not included and can offset part of that. Couples can test it in the couple calculator.

Frequently asked questions
What is the best way to compare student loan plans?
Compare total paid over the life of the loan, including any tax on forgiveness, not just the monthly payment. Start by confirming which plans you're eligible for, then whether PSLF applies, then run each plan on your income path.
Which repayment plans can I choose in 2026?
If all your loans were disbursed before July 1, 2026 and you haven't borrowed or consolidated since, you can choose IBR, RAP, the 10-year Standard plan and other legacy plans; PAYE and ICR end June 30, 2028. If you have any loan made on or after July 1, 2026, your choices are RAP or Tiered Standard.
Is the lowest monthly payment the cheapest plan?
Only on PSLF. Off PSLF, a lower payment usually stretches repayment and adds interest, and any forgiveness after 20 to 30 years is federally taxable. In our $300,000 attending example, the plan with the lowest payment cost about $147,000 more than refinancing.
Does Tiered Standard count for PSLF?
No. The Department of Education states that Tiered Standard is not a PSLF-qualifying plan. RAP, IBR and the 10-year Standard plan do qualify.